Engineering SADC
| The significant power generation program
in South Africa has brought both challenge
and opportunity to Murray & Roberts. |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
| Malose Chaba |
|
Andrew Langham |
|
Keith Smith |
|
|
| Engineering SADC |
| (R millions) |

|
|
|
Financial performance
Murray & Roberts Projects completed its first year as a newly consolidated
business, but its performance was muted by the delayed start of mechanical
erection on the South African power program.
Murray & Roberts Marine successfully completed its projects in Middle East
and secured a design and construct subcontract for the Gorgon project in
Western Australia.
Wade Walker suffered a significant decline in fortunes in the year, primarily
as a result of a cancelled major project that could not be replaced in an African
market severely impacted by the global financial crisis. A focus on cost and
a steady domestic market supported a reasonable performance in the year. |
 |
Medupi power station boiler mainframe |
| |
|
Murray & Roberts Projects |
|
|
Wade Walker |
|
|
Marine |
|
|
Genrec |
|
| |
|
2010 |
|
|
2009 |
|
|
2010 |
|
|
2009 |
|
|
2010 |
|
|
2009 |
|
|
2010 |
|
|
2009 |
|
| |
Revenues* |
744 |
|
|
675 |
|
|
313 |
|
|
1 058 |
|
|
351 |
|
|
515 |
|
|
476 |
|
|
444 |
|
| |
Operating profit* |
65 |
|
|
(11) |
|
|
35 |
|
|
328 |
|
|
77 |
|
|
97 |
|
|
(65) |
|
|
33 |
|
| |
Margin (%) |
8,7 |
|
|
– |
|
|
11,2 |
|
|
31,0 |
|
|
21,9 |
|
|
18,8 |
|
|
– |
|
|
7,4 |
|
| |
Assets* |
535 |
|
|
163 |
|
|
142 |
|
|
421 |
|
|
92 |
|
|
146 |
|
|
241 |
|
|
437 |
|
| |
People |
1 423 |
|
|
561 |
|
|
464 |
|
|
1 458 |
|
|
118 |
|
|
381 |
|
|
1 188 |
|
|
1 111 |
|
| |
LTIFR (Fatalities) |
0,4 (0) |
|
|
1,1 (0) |
|
|
4,5 (0) |
|
|
0,0 (0) |
|
|
1,2 (0) |
|
|
0,0 (0) |
|
|
1,5 (0) |
|
|
10,9 (0) |
|
| |
Order book* |
10 863 |
|
|
11 151 |
|
|
177 |
|
|
368 |
|
|
502 |
|
|
222 |
|
|
4 926 |
|
|
6 742 |
|
* R millions
Background
Murray & Roberts introduced mainstream engineering contracting into its portfolio of market
offerings through the Pelindaba nuclear project in the early 1960s and enhanced its capability
in the specialised marine infrastructure market with the acquisition of the southern hemisphere
operations of Danish contractor Christiani & Nielsen in the 1970s.
When requested by the South African Government to develop the capacity to provide
engineering services for its planned nuclear research facility at Pelindaba in 1960, Murray &
Roberts established Engineering Management Services (later rebranded Murray & Roberts
Engineering Solutions). This company went on to play a major role in the design and
construction of a number of major mining & minerals, oil & gas and general industrial projects in
South Africa and the region, including the Mossgas gas to liquids plant and offshore platform,
Hillside and Mozal aluminium smelters, and key projects for Sappi, Sasol, Kumba (Iscor), Anglo
American, BHP Billiton, Xstrata, De Beers and many others.
A mechanical, electrical, instrumentation and piping (MEIP) contracting capability was established
by the Group during the 1970s in KwaZulu Natal to serve the industrial expansion taking
place in the region. Major projects for Mondi, Sappi, Tongaat Hulett and Illovo established and
expanded their agri-industrial facilities over time. Subsequently, Sasol, Shell and Engen (Mobil)
became major clients in the petrochemical sector and many projects have been completed for
the mining and minerals sector.
Murray & Roberts Engineering Solutions and Murray & Roberts MEI were merged during
the year to create Murray & Roberts Projects, a major EPC contractor more appropriately
positioned to serve the minerals beneficiation, industrial, oil & gas, water and power sectors,
including nuclear, which offers significant opportunity to the Group into the future.
The acquisition in 2007 of specialist electrical and instrumentation contractor, Wade Walker,
has enhanced the Group’s potential offering to these sectors.
Market environment
The private sector natural resources and
industrial markets remained muted through
the year despite strong commodity price
increases. The predominance of activity
remained in public sector power generation
and infrastructure development programs.
The companies in this cluster are primarily
focused on the Group’s core competence
in industrial engineering, which if properly
applied in the early design and feasibility
phases of projects, offers significant value
to clients.
Leadership
Gary Wells was appointed managing director
of Murray & Roberts Projects in July 2009
and Keith Smith was appointed chairman of
the company in January 2010.
Tim Wakefield succeeded Tadhg Bergin as
managing director of Wade Walker in April
2010, who in turn had succeeded founder
Steve Walker in July 2009.
Ian Dryden is managing director of Murray &
Roberts Marine.
 |
| Heavy lift at Medupi |
|
Precision and safety
A major lift of 1 160 tonnes undertaken in
July 2010 to erect the roof of the first Medupi
boiler used a method called strand jacking
to ensure the highest levels of precision
and safety.
The process involved the lifting of a heavy
steel grid that will house the boiler onto a
104 metre high steel frame.
Strand jacking is a construction process in
which large construction elements such as
concrete slabs and steelwork are lifted into
position with computer-controlled hydraulic
jacks. Because the multiple jacks can be
moved in unison and with great precision,
heavy structures can be assembled at
ground level and then lifted into position
rather than being built at higher levels.
This allows for increased safety and it
reduces costs.
The Medupi heavy lift was successfully
completed with support from Swiss
subcontractor, Hebetec Engineering,
and Murray & Roberts company, Freyssinet.
The transfer of valuable skills during
the process will enable Murray & Roberts
to complete the process for the other
Medupi boilers. |
Operations
These businesses leverage design, engineering, project and construction management
expertise to deliver major projects in the energy, natural resources and industrial sectors.
| Murray & Roberts Projects |
| |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Gary Wells |
|
Adrian Plantema |
|
Peter Wilson |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Murray & Roberts Projects
The company is focused on the power sector, mining & minerals beneficiation, downstream oil
& gas and is exploring the potential in the water supply sector.
Murray & Roberts Projects is the erection contractor for the twelve boiler house units at Medupi
and Kusile coal fired power stations. The company is also leader of the in-house consortium,
including Genrec as structural steel fabricator and Energy Fabrication as ducting fabricator.
The mechanical erection phase at Medupi was delayed by eleven months and commenced
in February 2010. However, ongoing delays with the overall design and the civil engineering
foundations continue to hamper progress. Approximately 6 000 tonnes of a total 18 500 tonnes
of structural steelwork have been erected on the first boiler unit and welding of pressure parts
for boiler assembly has progressed well. A major lift of 1 160 tonnes to erect the roof section
of the first boiler was completed early in July 2010.
Early stage planning and mobilisation is underway at Kusile, with commencement of erection
delayed more than nine months to later in 2010. First power into the national grid from Medupi
is rescheduled to mid-2012 with Kusile following twelve months later.
Fabrication of the structural steelwork by Genrec has been hampered by late design and
significant scope change, which has also impacted fabrication of ductwork by Energy
Fabrication operating from its purpose built facility on site at Medupi.
Murray & Roberts Projects has been awarded a two-year EPC joint venture contract for the
receiving tank farm located at Heidelberg (Terminal 2) of Transnet’s National Multi-Product
Pipeline. The scope of the project includes design, supply and erection of the multi-fuel tank
farm to a capacity of
178 000 m³.
The company has lodged a proposal to a Chinese power station contractor together with
Murray & Roberts Construction and Concor for multidisciplinary construction at Xstrata’s
Lesedi 300 MW coal fired power plant at the Tweefontein coal mine in Mpumalanga.
An expression of interest has been lodged in respect of IPP proposals for the Coega
Development Corporation 3 200 MW combined cycle gas turbine power plant, which plans to
use regasified imported liquid natural gas (LNG).
| Murray & Roberts Marine |
| |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
|
| Ian Dryden |
|
Jason Coleman |
|
Martin Lindsay-Scott |
|
Derek Paul |
|
Mike Scott |
|
|
Murray & Roberts Marine
Murray & Roberts Marine, in joint venture, completed the Al Raha sea wall project in Abu Dhabi
ahead of schedule in December 2009. Other smaller seawall projects in the region have also
been completed. Together, these projects involved the design and construction of more than
20 kilometres of seawall protection for new developments.
The design and construction of a pipe stringing yard for the Abu Dhabi Crude Oil Pipeline
(ADCOP) in Fujairah was completed in July 2010.
The project to design and construct the marine pipeline intake for Uramin’s Trekkopje
desalination plant in Namibia was impacted by geological variation and is due for completion
after the 2010 year end.
Murray & Roberts Marine has been awarded a joint venture subcontract to design and
construct the material offloading facility for the Gorgon Project in Western Australia. The local
partner has experienced liquidity problems and a solution with Clough has been finalised.
| Wade Walker |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
|
| Tim Wakefield |
|
Stuart Buss |
|
Wade Walker
 |
| Al Raha sea wall project in Abu Dhabi |
The AngloGold Ashanti Iduapriem gold mine expansion project in Ghana was completed in
the year, but little new opportunity became available in Africa as the global financial crisis
continued to subdue investment in mining projects on the continent. Some work was acquired
on smaller projects for First Quantum’s Kansanshi copper mine in Zambia and at Guelb
Moghrein in Mauritania.
The company focused on the South African market where the contract for electrical work at all
the Gautrain stations and tunnels proceeded well. Negotiations are well advanced to secure a
long term subcontract with Alstom for instrumentation work connecting the Medupi turbines,
boilers and water treatment works.
| Genrec |
|
|
| |
|
|
 |
|
 |
| Laurence Savage |
|
Geoff Mowatt |
Genrec
Established in the 1950s, Genrec is a leading steel fabrication and erection contractor that
has played a key role in numerous major infrastructural projects,
 |
| Genrec delivers steel columns to Medupi |
including the Matimba Power
Station and the Mossgas refinery in South Africa, and the iconic Burj al Arab Hotel in Dubai.
Murray & Roberts acquired its first 30% investment in the company in 1974 and gained control
of the business in the 1980s.
Genrec has focused exclusively on its steel fabrication contracts for the Medupi and Kusile power
stations during the year. The company was impacted by significant challenges associated
with delays and design changes in these contracts.
Genrec has the responsibility to detail engineer and fabricate about 240 000 tonnes of
structural steel over a period of five years for the two thermal power station projects. A major
upgrade was undertaken to increase production capacity to around 30 000 tonnes per annum
and the company commenced delivery of structural steel to Medupi for the first boiler in 2009.
Basic engineering and technical support is the responsibility of Hitachi Power which secured
the contract to design, build and commission the twelve boiler house units for the power
stations. This process has suffered significant delay and disruption as a result of late basic
engineering and an unreasonable subsequent sequence of design changes and variations. This
has severely hampered detailed design and production efficiency at Genrec. Notwithstanding,
the Group has made a significant investment to overcome the challenges and ensure the best
possible outcome for South Africa’s critical power program.
Genrec has subsequently improved production output and people productivity and initiated
a drive to contain costs without compromising quality. A zero tolerance approach to safety is
reflected in the decline in the company’s LTIFR to 1,5 (2009: 10,9).
Laurence Savage joined the Group in August 2009 as managing director of Hall Longmore.
He was appointed managing director of Genrec from February 2010, where he has made a
significant difference in dealing with the design disruption on the Medupi and Kusile projects.
Genrec will only seek new opportunities from 2012 after the power station contracts peak.
| UCW |
| |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Gary Steinmetz |
|
Guy Melville |
|
Craig Holden |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
UCW manufacturing facility
|
UCW
Union Carriage and Wagon (UCW) was established in the 1950s to serve the South African
rolling stock market in both passenger and freight sectors, and built the prestigious Blue Train
in 1972. Murray & Roberts acquired ownership of the company through its acquisition of
Standard Engineering in the early 1990s.
UCW has two major long term contracts to design, build and systems integrate the Ore Line
and Coal Line locomotive projects as part of Transnet’s Main Line Locomotive Investment
Program. The contracts are in partnership with Mitsui and Toshiba and involve the supply of
110 new class 19E locomotives for the Coal Line corridor and 44 new class 15E locomotives
for the Ore Line project. The company has delivered 27 of the 19E units to date, with 23 of
these in active operation. In addition, it has delivered 10 of the 15E units, with an additional
seven units on the production line. While both projects are running behind schedule due to
historic challenges in the business, the introduction of more effective systems and a quality
network has resulted in a significant improvement in the production cycle.
A three year project to refurbish 10M4 and 5M2A coaches for PRASA was completed in March
2010. UCW had delivered all 81 vehicles for Gautrain by September 2010.
The company was impacted by high interest charges in 2010 due to stock holding costs
associated with delays in the progress of its locomotive contracts and a substantial outstanding
payment by a major client.
Gary Steinmetz joined the Group and was appointed managing director of UCW from October
2009. He has brought a rare experience in complex systems fabrication and assembly to the
Group and his partnership with operations director Craig Holden has significantly improved the
performance of the company. A strong focus on safety has resulted in a significant reduction
in the LTIFR to 5,1 (2009: 11,4).
UCW is awaiting confirmation of extensions to its 15E locomotive and PRASA coach
refurbishment contracts and is pursuing other opportunities in the domestic and SADC markets.
Sustainability
A focus on safety across the cluster saw no fatalities or major incidents in the year. Murray
& Roberts Projects reduced its LTIFR to 0,4 (2009: 1,1). Murray & Roberts Marine reported
an LTIFR of 1,2 (2009: 0,0) and Wade Walker’s LTIFR of 4,5 (2009: 0,0) was the result of five
injuries suffered by a subcontractor in a road accident on the Gautrain project against a sharp
reduction in hours worked during the year.
 |
UCW assembled 81 Gautrain vehicles |
Murray & Roberts Projects increased capacity in human resource, health & safety, commercial
and planning management through the year. The Medupi and Kusile management teams were
restructured to improve overall effectiveness in the environment of delays and disruption that
prevailed through the year.
The Group’s integrated ERP system was enhanced to improve the standard of quality and
discipline in project management and a sustainable development program was introduced to
build core competencies in-house. This includes a key strategic drive to strengthen engineering
competence and increase activity in the front-end engineering phase of projects. The company
concluded agreements with two level 1 BBBEE engineering companies.
Murray & Roberts Marine and Wade Walker have strong operations management and business
systems appropriate to the nature of the businesses.
Prospects
The Medupi and Kusile boiler projects make up about 40% of the Group’s order book and
provide an extended baseload of activity until 2016. While Murray & Roberts Projects is
pursuing opportunities with independent power producers in South Africa, it is also positioning
itself for future involvement in the minerals beneficiation, oil & gas and water sectors.
Murray & Roberts Marine expects to leverage market value from relationships established with
new clients in recent years and is pursuing opportunities in the domestic market as well as
Malaysia and East Africa.
Wade Walker has broadened the traditional scope of its business to include the power sector
in the domestic market and Africa.
| Malose Chaba |
Andrew Langham |
|